Sunday, October 21, 2012

Review: MakeupGeek Eyeshadows!

Hey Everyone!!!

   I have quite the exciting review for you today! I was contacted by MakeupGeek to be a part of their Idea Gallery and to also receive 12 of their eyeshadows. I was so excited to be contacted from them, so I quickly jumped on the opportunity and picked my 12 shadows! The second they came in the mail I opened them up and swatched them and let me just say I was HAPPILY surprised! I will get on to the swatches and give my full opinion at the end.... I know you are all more excited to see these amazing shadows!

Each photo was taken in artificial lighting with no flash.

I did not swatch the shadows over a base to show their true opacity.

I will state Makeupgeek's description of each shadow, followed by my personal view of the each shadow.

From left to right: Mocha, Cocoa Bear, Purely Naked, & Vanilla Bean

MUG: Deep matte brown

Mocha is a beautiful “teddy bear” matte dark brown. This shadow is perfect for deepening the crease of a neutral smokey eye!

Cocoa Bear:

MUG: Matte reddish brown

Cocoa Bear is a warm toned reddish brown, it kind of yields an orange tone. This shadow would go great with Mocha.

Purely Naked:

MUG: Shimmery tan

I found Purely Naked to be a slightly peachy shimmery tan. This is a perfect highlight or all over the lid color.

Vanilla Bean:

MUG: Simple but smooth shadow that has a matte finish with just the slightest sheen.

This shadow is quite similar to Brule from MAC, which is my holy grail highlight shadow! I may just have to swap to Vanilla Bean, since it's a much cheaper alternative!

From left to right: Sensuous, Unexpected, Moondust, & Shimma Shimma

MUG: Shimmery purple with flecks of silver.

I found sensuous to be a plum purple with silver and gold flecks throughout. On the swatch it didn’t have as strong of color payoff that I was hoping for as it took about 2-3 layers to get it the way it looks in the swatch, but it is still a gorgeous purple and great for hazel eyes!


MUG: Matte pale pink brown.

I really like this shadow! Unexpected has great color payoff and it a dusty purple with a slight brown undertone. This shadow looks amazing with Sensuous.


MUG: Metallic silver taupe

I found Moondust to be a silver taupe shadow with a slight greenish undertone. This is one of the more true metallic shadows out of the bunch.

Shimma Shimma:

MUG: Metallic Campagne

Shimma Shimma is another pure metallic shade; it is a metallic version of Vanilla Bean. I really love this shadow as an inner corner highlight and to add an extra boost to under the brow.

From left to right: Envy, Corrupt, Peacock, & Razzleberry

MUG: Deep metallic green.

I was slightly disappointed with the way that this swatch came out because I was expecting more of a metallic deep, rich green. I found this shadow to be more of a blackened hunter green with silver shimmer throughout and no metallic sheen. Envy is still a beautiful green that would go great with Moondust.


MUG: Intense matte black with a very subtle sparkle.

Corrupt is perhaps one of the darkest matte blacks out there. I absolutely love how soft and deep this shadow is! Definitely a new holy grail black for me!


MUG: Matte deep teal blue.

Peacock was also another shadow that I had a different vision of judging by the shadow in the pan. The swatch came out to be more of a blue than a teal, although I can see the greenish undertone. Either way, this is still a beautiful shadow.


MUG: Raspberry pink with gold shimmer.

Razzleberry is a beautiful pinkish red with gold shimmer throughout.

These shadows truly surprised me with how soft and pigmented they are. There was only one that I wasn't as impressed with the pigmentation of (Sensuous) and it does take a little bit more work to get this shadow to true opacity. Envy was the only shadow that I was disappointed with in that with the online swatch, it looked like a much more vibrant green, but it seems to be a black based hunter green; still a gorgeous shadow though. 

All of the shadows are extremely blendable and they are so easy to work with. I found the mattes to perform much better than some of the mattes from MAC as they are much softer and more pigmented. 

I would highly recommend giving Makeupgeek shadows a try! They are a little more than half the price of a MAC shadow and apply beautifully! Makeupgeek shadows can be purchased in pan form for $5.99 and in compact form for $7.99.

Here is a look I did using the Makeupgeek shadows!

Revlon Colorstay Foundation 150 Buff Chamois & 180 Sand Beige
MAC Blush in Margin & Springsheen
Benefit Hoola Bronzer
theBalm Bahama Mama Bronzer
theBalm Mary-Lou Manizer

MUG Shadows: Corrupt, Vanilla Bean, Moondust, Unexpected, Sensuous, Shimma Shimma
Inglot Gel Liner #77
Loreal Collagen Mascara and Maybelline Mega Plush Volum' Express Mascara in Blackest Black

Shiro Cosmetics Ridiculously Photogenic

My favorites are Corrupt, Vanilla Bean, Moondust, & Unexpected! Have you tried any Makeupgeek shadows? If so, which are your favorites?

- Alicia

**DISCLAIMER** Some or all products in this post have been provided by the brands stated for review or use. All opinions are my own and it is my obligation to give my readers an honest review of any products received.




  1. Very pretty colours/makeup look and nice review, Makeup Geek eye shadows are on my wishlist so are there gel liners :)

    1. Thank you! I definitely want to try their gel liners too! I have had my eyes on those for a while!

  2. I cannot WAIT to buy some of these!! Hopefully soon ;) Razzleberry is too cute of a name lol!

    1. They are totally worth the buy! I am going to get some more once I'm not so broke haha! I think I'm going to use that one in my next look with them, it's such a pretty color!